[Season 1 !Season 2 ]
This takes the Magic Realism of Wonderfalls to an extreme length, wrapping it up in OTT trappings reminiscent of Lemony Snickett . Jim Dale's sickly-sweet narration is the icing on the cake (or pie, if you prefer).
The ep starts with a thorough introduction to the concept, starting with the protagonist's childhood. The Pie-Maker is owner/manager/chef of a restuarant, the Pie Hole. He has a superpower - he can magically revive dead people, but only for 60 seconds. This power comes in useful for solving murders ...
The pie-maker's newest corpse is his childhood friend, Lonely Tourist Charlotte 'Chuck' Charles ( Anna Friel ). He can't bring himself to return her to death when her minute is up ... but if he ever touches her again, she'll die for certain. She died under mysterious circumstances, so he brings her back permanently and she joins the crime-busting team to solve her own murder.
The Pie-Holers pursue an escaped convict, as he leaves a trail of bodies in his wake.
Horse-racing Jockeys are being killed by the ghost of a dead Jockey. Olive used to be a jockey - is she on the ghost's hit-list?
A man is murdered, and says that his wife did it. Unfortunately he's a polygamist, and he has 4 wives! They're dog-breeders, and each one has a different Breed and training speciality. The Pie Holers must split up and each investigate a different suspect.
Someone boobytraps a scratch-and-sniff book. It seems like someone's trying to kill the author. The main suspect is a sewer-dwelling smell-lover (Peewee Herman).
A new shop starts up - a Sweet Shop. This is unexpected competition for the Pie Shop. And when one of the owners ends up dead, the Pie-Maker is the main suspect.
Olive Snook ( Kristin Chenoweth ) discovers that Charlotte 'Chuck' Charles ( Anna Friel ) is the pie-maker's girlfriend. She is jealous, but they start to bond ...
This week's victim was murdered and buried inside a snowman. He's the first victim of a serial-killer!
Emerson Cod is hired for a Missing Persons case. Yes, the gumshoe manages to get a realistic case, not just another homicide. The body count of this show is shocking, as is the fact that the police mess up so many cases that everyone has to hire a PI to get justice!
It turns out that the missing girl ran away to join the circus. Then the bodies start piling up.
Blondie gave away all her worldly goods and became a nun.
A man is murdered, and two people hire P.I. Emerson Cod to catch the killer. This means that both of them are suspects, so Emerson and his very Caucasian-looking mother team up to interrogate them. Despite their apparently close relationship, he has yet to tell her that she's a grandmother.
Dead girl and blondie are flatmates now. They even go undercover together, as Friend-Escorts (Frescorts).
With his sidekicks paired off, the poor Pie-Maker is lonelier than ever as a result.
Emmerson Cod the PI gets a chinese meal delivered, and there is a secret message in the fortune cookie. He investigates a gambling ring at the Chinese restaurant. One suspect is a beautiful woman who has trained Emmerson Cod like he was her pet.
The girls try to track down the pie-maker's dad. They discover that he has 2 half-brothers.
A friend of Charlotte's dad is in town. He knows the parents' secrets, and he's after something ...
It turns out that The Piemaker's dad abandoned him, and started a new family. Now the Piemaker has twin half-brothers who are both stage magicians. The normally even-tempered Piemaker is not pleased by these developments.
Emmerson Cod the PI is hired to find out who is killing the Magician's animals.
A friend of Charlotte's dad is in town. He knows the parents' secrets, and he's after something ...
Lawyer Ethan Philips ( Star Trek: VGR ) hires Emerson Cod to discover who murdered his client, a reclusive miserly billionaire. The suspects include the bimbo trophy wife and a Robin Hood burglar. Shades of Green Arrow , perhaps?
Back in the on-going subplot, Chuck's aunt has a new BF, who used to be a friend of Chuck's dad. He's got plans of his own. The mysterious stranger closes in on Chuck's secret. He doesn't care about it, he only wants Chuck's father's watch. but Chuck and the pie-maker may have to revive the only other person who knew the secret - Chuck's father himself!
Chuck got the Pie-Maker to raise her dad. But she wanted daddy back permanently. Naturally, someone else died - so Chuck and Emerson Cod have to clean up the mess.
The pie-maker and Blondie go to their annual contest, the Best in belly Comfort Food contest. Naturally, someone dies under mysterious circumstances. One of the other contestants is murdered, and they have to find the killer. The dynamic duo must solve the case themselves.
Kristen Chenoweth is only about half the height of the pie-maker, but she makes up for it by showing a lot of cleavage.
The team investigate Merle McQuoddy, who returned home after being marooned for years. But now he is a suspect in a murder ...
Emerson has rivals - a Norwegian CSI team, led by Orlando Jones ( Evolution, Time Machine ). Blondie ( Kristen Chenoweth ) feels left out because the others won't tell her Chuck's secret, so she decides to join the Norwegians.
The Pie-maker is stalked by a mysterious stranger.
The pie-maker decides that after the events of the previous ep, he will no longer use his super-power of raising the dead.
Blondie ( Kristen Chenoweth ) meets up with her childhood kidnappers. Randy the taxidermist (David Arquette) comes along to make disguises for them.
Emerson Cod and Anna Friel investigate the mysterious death of a Department Store's window-display designer. Willie Garson ( Stargate SG-1 ) is the Department Store's owner.
Emerson Cod is back together with the dog-training woman. To complicate things, he gets hired to hunt down murder suspect Gina Torres - the baby-mamma who dumped him, taking their daughter with her! The gold-digging con-woman is the main suspect.
Meanwhile, Blondie dates David Arquette.
The Darling Mermaid Darlings go to see a show by their rivals, Wendy Malick and her sister. But when one of the rivals gets killed mysteriously, the Darling Mermaid Darlings have to come out of retirement.
The show was wound up. But the makers managed to give it some proper closure.